Re: Where to report bugs in website 'search.cpan.org' ?

On Wed, Sep 7, 2016 at 11:56 PM, Linda A. Walsh <[email protected]> wrote:

>
> Moving this question to module-authors as per David G.'s feedback.
>
> I was looking for available mail-filtering, aka Milter, mods, and
> came across Mail-Milter.
>
> I noticed it has 1 review rating it a single *.  and it wanted to
> know if the review was helpful -- and it wasn't --
> as it doesn't say *what* version the review was about.
>
> The reviews seem to be generally "worthless", if they don't
> tell me which version is being reviewed.  A comment about a module
> from V0.0.1 isn't very useful for a module at version 2.3.7 (as a
> randomly chosen example).
>
> This brings up a few requests/ideas for improvement:
>
> 1) Could the version number a review refers to be included?
>
> For comments already posted, either, mark them as too old to
> to have included the reviewed version, OR, *IF* the date
> of the review is known (it probably should be included in the
> review anyway), then match it to the highest version before
> the review was added.
>
> 2) There should be a way of "closing out" reviews that would have
> really been better placed as bugs or RFE's, that have been addressed
> (i.e. bug-fixed, or feature-added, etc...).
>
> As it stands now, reviews don't say anything about current versions
> and for "bug-fix" reviews, there's no way to indicate the bug was
> fixed and the review doesn't apply to a more current version.  There
> is also no way to respond to a review to mention that anything has changed
> or been fixed.  Any response ends up as another, _unconnected_ comment --
> not very useful.
>
> Thoughts?  Ideas/feedback?
> Thanks...
>
>
>
>
(Resending as it didn't go to the list)

These issues are mostly regarding the cpanratings site itself, which is not
part of search.cpan.org. You can find its issue tracker here:
https://github.com/perlorg/perlweb/issues

And you might also find this discussion interesting, regarding similar
links from metacpan.org: https://github.com/metacpan/metacpan-web/
issues/1653