Re: SATA or external drive recommendations?

Ping -- does anyone have recommendations on drives?

As detailed below, the drive I recently bought tests bad with
cdparanoia, and indeed generates spectactularly bad rips even on clean
CDs, full of staticky artifacts.  I'd like to get a drive that will
work, but don't want to get burned again.

thanks.

--eric

On Sat, Dec 20, 2008 at 6:42 PM, Eric Altendorf <[email protected]> wrote:
> I just spent the last 6 hours or so testing various things to
> determine why I was getting obvious and really awful skips and other
> audible defects with scratched CDs in cdparanoia.
>
> Turns out it is probably due to my new drive being one of the crappy
> ones with a cache that cdparanoia doesn't know how to model (yet),
> since 'cdparanoia -A' fairly reliably returns "PARANOIA MAY NOT BE
> TRUSTWORTHY WITH THIS DRIVE!".  I've sent several analysis logs to
> paranoia-dev, so hopefully that will help, but I have a whole bunch of
> CDs I'd like to rip ASAP, so I would probably rather not wait and
> instead just get a new drive that doesn't suck.
>
> I had a PATA drive that worked fine, but I had to replace my mobo and
> accidentally got one without enough PATA connectors, so I bought a new
> SATA drive.  It's the new SATA that won't rip reliably.  So, I'm
> looking for a SATA that works well with cdparanoia, or an external.
> Thanks!
>
> frustrated,
>
> --eric
>