Re: LIRC 0.10.1 seems to hate my remote..

Well, it probably won't be the answer you look for, but I had a similar
problem with lirc_atiusb: worked fine for 10yrs but any update ended up
in a desaster;
So I decided to freeze this box at Debian 5.0 and kernel 2.6.32 with
lirc 0.8.5 - as it "just works perfectly" for more than 10yrs..
rather than to replace 15 working and proven remotes with all the logic
behind it..

Newer software is not always better :( and as this system isn't
accesible even from the "normal" LAN (or outside), having some spare HW,
I'm pretty fine with that.

greets, Michael

On 25.03.19 20:13, Marc Tousignant wrote:
> It is a weird situation, and I did not have the issue using
> kernel-3.16.5 and LIRC 0.9.0, I am now using kernel-4.17.19 with LIRC
> 0.10.1 on 2 nearly identical systems. The only difference between them
> is that on one I have a Lenovo USB IR receiver and on the other I have
> an HP IR receiver. This should not matter as they have never mattered in
> the past and have been perfectly fine since an 0.8 build of LIRC.
> 
> For a remote I have a Logitech Harmony Ultimate that is programmed as a
> Tivo_S2, as well as a slim HP MCE remote. Again, these were operational
> on the 0.9.0 version, but after 2+ years I decided to upgrade the
> systems, kernel LIRC and everything else.
> 
>  
> 
> Now on to the issue. On boot, the Logitech remote will not work. It will
> not control the program I want it to, and I do not see any messages in
> IRW that it is even seeing the button presses. I do however see the LED
> on the receiver acknowledge that it sees a button press.
> 
> If I use the MCE remote, the program responds and IRW prints the button
> presses, but here is where it gets weird. Now that I have used the MCE
> remote, the Logitech starts working… I can use the Logitech perfectly
> fine any button I press works, I see a response in the program and I see
> a IRW printout if I have it open.
> 
> Stranger still, after a period of time of inactivity, LIRC again stops
> “seeing” the Logitech again.. But again, if I use the MCE remote first,
> then the Logitech works again after that. It is almost like LIRC is
> going to “sleep” and the MCE remote needs to “wake” it up.
> 
>  
> 
> Another solution seems to be to restart LIRCD, then the Logitech works,
> but still has the timeout after a few mins.. and I need to use the MCE
> remote again, or restart LIRCD again.
> 
>  
> 
> Looking for ideas here, other than setting up a cronjob to restart LIRC
> every few mins, or using 2 remotes..
> 
>  
> 
> MarcT
> 
> 


-- 
Für Rückfragen stehe ich jederzeit gerne zur Verfügung.

Mit freundlichen Grüssen

Michael Markstaller
Softwareentwicklung & IT-Dienstleistungen

Am Birkengarten 19b
82024 Taufkirchen
Tel: +49-89-21553825, Mobile: +49-179-2080789
USt-ID: DE293191950