Re: Default Template discussion

Claudia,

Maybe there is some misunderstanding here.
Currently, the list of attachments of a page is only visible in the
attachement tab.
(It used to be at the bottom of the page)
So it is actually visible only once.

On 7/20/07, Claudia Frers <[email protected]> wrote:
> Wiki Page specific Quick Links (cont'd from Alex's attachment query)
> I know that the content of an Edit Page will also be shown twice: in its
> edit form and view form.However, its somehow confusing to see a list of
> attachments twice in each tab (View, Attach). Thus my first suggestion to
> keep the Add Attachment under the Edit tab was born.



> So here's a bit different scenario which I would have kep to myself but got
> provoked by Alex's email.
> Imagine only 3 tabs:  View Edit Info
>
> The View tab contains the following horizontal toggle buttons:
>  show/hide attachments
>  show/hide comments
>
> The edit tab contains the following horizontal buttons:
>  add comment
>  add attachment
>
> Alternatively(as delete is not available as a feature yet):
> The edit tab contains the following horizontal toggle buttons:
>  add/delete comment
>  add/delete attachment
>
> I'd like to hear what you guys see as the cons and pro of this idea may be.

I'd rather keep the current Attach TAB approach. It groups all
attachment related functionality.
So it is easy for a user where to go for attachment stuff.

However, the comment add button in the EDIT tab makes sense to me.
(note there is no such thing as a delete comment as commenting is
really plain basis today)

dirk

dirk