Re: RFC: drop bevel

Semantics and dictionaries aside, I'm making the observation that in 
GUIs border and bevel are typically matching the definitions I 
provided. My vote is to keep them separate. I see several paths to 
follow:

1) border is a widget. If one must be a proxy then border should be a 
proxy for bevel wherein the color for top-left is identical to 
bottom-right. The downside to being a proxy is that a bevel probably 
takes nominally longer to draw.

2) border and bevel are both attributes of _all_ widgets.

3) implementing CSS 1's box properties: 
http://www.w3.org/TR/CSS1#box-properties, perhaps with the caveat that 
all length's are pixel based. (for now?) The inset and outset values 
for the border-style property being inner and outer bevels.

I haven't been following your hard work as closely as I should be, but 
I lean heavily towards option 3 and fallback on 2. Then again I'm not 
the one doing the work. :\

Corey


On Wednesday, October 29, 2003, at 05:44 AM, Charles Goodwin wrote:

> Corey Jewett wrote:
>> A border is a one color outline that gives a space definition or 
>> focus.
>> A bevel is a two color (top and left, bottom and right) outline that 
>> gives 'dimension'. The top-left color is given slight preference in 
>> the corners where it meets the bottom-right color. Bevels, depending 
>> on color, are raised or lowered.
>> A bevel widget can emulate a border widget by using only one color. 
>> If this is what you are proposing then perhaps we should rename the 
>> widget. I propose 'outline'.
>
> I disagree with you on the semantics of this one.
>
> A bevel is a type of border, one that gives the impression of being 
> raised from or set into a surface.
>
> A border is just something that surrounds/expands upon the edge of an 
> area.  It does not have to be a single colour, nor a uniform width.
>
> From dictionary.com, the definition of border:
>    1. A part that forms the outer edge of something.
>    2. A decorative strip around the edge of something, such as fabric.
>    3. A strip of ground, as at the edge of a garden or walk, in which
>       ornamental plants or shrubs are planted.
>    4. The line or frontier area separating political divisions or
>       geographic regions; a boundary.
>
> At best, bevel will end up being a proxy to the borders available for 
> a theme.  Is it really needed?  Is it really wanted?
>
> <bevel form="up" thickness="1" />
> <border name="bevel1up" />
>
> I'm not fussed, I just thought it was a little unecessary to keep 
> bevel given the new border code (which I'm working on at the moment).
>
> - Charlie
>
>
> _______________________________________________
> widgets mailing list
> [email protected]
> http://lists.xwt.org/listinfo/widgets
>