VLAN bug (was Re: [m0n0wall] setting VLAN)

Ok,

I´m now pretty sure I´ve hit on a bug with vlans on 1.3

I´ve downgraded the machine to version 1.235, then created the vlan via 
console. It worked immediately. The same procedure with 1.3 is not 
working. I´ve tried to set vlan both via Web interface and through 
console, and neither of them gets vlans working. What would be now the 
appropriate way to fill a bug report? Should I just send a mail to the 
development mail list?

One curiosity is that 1.235 indicated the name of the interfaces as rl0 
and rl1, while 1.3 is indicating re0 and re1. I guess that´s because 
they are using FreeBSD 4 and FreeBSD 6, respectively.

Tks,

Roberto Greiner


On 14/12/2009 11:19, Roberto Greiner wrote:
> I´ve made another test, installing a sniffer checking the output of 
> the box. To my surprise, despite the configurations I mentioned 
> (Creting the VLAN, assigning it tom the LAN interface, setting the LAN 
> IP address), the packets are coming out from the interface without the 
> 802.1q headers.
>
> Now, is it a bug (Monowall is not creating;using 802.1q), or did I 
> miss some step to force monowall to use the VLAN?
>
> Tks,
>
> Roberto
>
>
>
> On 14/12/2009 10:35, Roberto Greiner wrote:
>> It´s on the LAN interface, which by default has a 'permit any any' 
>> rule, which I didn´t change. In any case, just to be sure, I changed 
>> the default rule, removing the source address limitation (form 'LAN 
>> subnet' to 'any'), but still no results.
>>
>> Any ideas on somewhere else I could be missing something?
>>
>> Thanks,
>>
>> Roberto
>>
>> On 11/12/2009 19:23, Jewell, Michael wrote:
>>> Firewall rules?  No rules means default deny.
>>>
>>>> -----Original Message-----
>>>> From: Roberto Greiner [mailto:[email protected]]
>>>> Sent: Friday, December 11, 2009 2:58 PM
>>>> Cc: [email protected]
>>>> Subject: [m0n0wall] setting VLAN
>>>>
>>>> Hi,
>>>>
>>>> I'm struggling somewhat with something that should be easy.
>>>>
>>>> Inside a XenCitrix Box, I've set a virtual monowall 1.3. I would 
>>>> like to
>>>> set the LAN interface to work in a given VLAN (say vlan 10).
>>>>
>>>> To do that, in Interfaces(assign)/VLAN I've create the VLAN with id 
>>>> 10,
>>>> on the internal physical interface (re1 here. re0 is the WAN 
>>>> interface).
>>>>
>>>> Next, in Interfaces(assign)/VLAN I've set the LAN interface to be this
>>>> new VLAN.
>>>>
>>>> After reboot, I've set the IP address (172.16.0.2, for tests).
>>>>
>>>> Unfortunately, it did not work. Other virtual machines in the same
>>>> physical server do manage to acess this same vlan properly (Tested 
>>>> with
>>>> a Debian install). From the Monowall install, with icmp, I can't reach
>>>> other machines, and neither do other machines reach the server.
>>>>
>>>> Did I miss something? According to 
>>>> http://m0n0.ch/wall/hardware.php, re
>>>> interfaces do support vlans.
>>>>
>>>> Thank you for your help,
>>>>
>>>> Roberto Greiner
>>>>
>>>> -- 
>>>>     -----------------------------------------------------
>>>>                   Marcos Roberto Greiner
>>>>
>>>>      Os otimistas acham que estamos no melhor dos mundos
>>>>       Os pessimistas tem medo de que isto seja verdade
>>>>                                     James Branch Cabell
>>>>     -----------------------------------------------------
>>>>
>>>>
>>>> ---------------------------------------------------------------------
>>>> To unsubscribe, e-mail: [email protected]
>>>> For additional commands, e-mail: [email protected]
>>
>>
>
>


-- 
   -----------------------------------------------------
                 Marcos Roberto Greiner

    Os otimistas acham que estamos no melhor dos mundos
     Os pessimistas tem medo de que isto seja verdade
                                   James Branch Cabell
   -----------------------------------------------------