Re: Tortoise CVS - Files not set read-only on checkout

Hello Arthur,

Thanks for the quick response, I've upgraded our Windows CVS Server to 2.5.04 (Zen) Build 3510 and re-run test using TortoiseCVS 1.10.10.  As expected, the test failed, I say as expected as the email from Torsten implies that it won't work unless the version of Tortoise is built with #define MARCH_HARE_BUILD set. 

Before looking into obtaining a copy of Tortoise compiled with this setting, I asked my colleague Alan Dunkley to perform a similar test using a Linux Client. Issuing the following commands to a Linux server worked fine, e.g. test.txt was read-only. However issuing the same commands to a Windows CVS server resulted in test.txt being read-write.

mkdir test1 test2
cd test1
cvs checkout cvs-test
cd cvs-test
cvs watch on test.txt
cd ../../
cd test2
cvs checkout cvs-test
ls -l cvs-test

I have no idea if this is due to the Windows server requiring a configuration change, its currently running with default settings. Something I will look into later. Any idea's would be appreciated.

Thanks
Mike

-----Original Message-----
From: Arthur Barrett [mailto:arthur.barrett-qn/[email protected]] 
Sent: 03 September 2009 22:12
To: Cuff, Mike; tortoisecvs-users-5NWGOfrQmneRv+LV9MX5uipxlwaOVQ5f@public.gmane.org
Subject: RE: [TortoiseCVS] Tortoise CVS - Files not set read-only on checkout

Hi Mike,

> CVS server version: Concurrent Versions System 
> (CVSNT) 2.5.04 (Zen) Build 3236 ()

We did just recently release some important updates to this old release,
you may want to consider upgrading.  In particular this re-release
supports HPUX pa-risc and itanium servers:
http://cvsnt.org/pipermail/cvsnt/2009-August/032311.html

> I am experimenting TortoiseCVS, creating modules 
> with the "Checkout read-only" option ticked.  

I think this is some of the code we submitted and Torsten kindly
integrated - it looks like you have found a problem with it (probably
either because it was originally tested on 2.5.03 server, there is a
compatibility problem between 2.5.03 client and 2.5.04 server, or
something got missed in Tortsten's usually flawless integration).

However the 'usual' purpose of this feature is to enforce either
'co-operative' locking or 'reserved' locking - where developers are
either required to 'cvs edit' a file before working on it or required to
exclusively 'cvs edit' a file before working on it.  The server must be
involved in these tasks so it is NOT possible for a single checkbox on
the TortoiseCVS client to enable it - you need to enable the policy on
the server and set each file to the correct mode, eg:

 CVSROOT=:sspi:evs-teamserver:/cvs-repository/dtcs
 In D:\PB Projects\testlib5: 
 "cvs.exe" update -kvx test.bas

 CVSROOT=:sspi:evs-teamserver:/cvs-repository/dtcs
 In D:\PB Projects\testlib5: 
 "cvs.exe" -q commit -f -m "change file mode" test.bas
 
The CVSNT/TortoiseCVS ecosystem has all the freedoms of GPL software,
but that doesn't make learning it any easier - which is why we provide
books and training etc:
http://march-hare.com/cvsnt/features/book/en.asp

We have a few differences in our own TortoiseCVS development tree for
CVS Suite, and I have been trying to package them up for Torsten for
some time - looks like it'll be another couple of months though...  For
those interested: I think the 'bug' in the watches from Mikes trace is
this line:

  In D:\PB Projects\testlib5: 
  "cvs.exe" -q watch on
  CVSROOT=:sspi:evs-teamserver:/cvs-repository/dtcs
 
Shouldn't that be "cvs watch on readonly" ?  I have a vague recollection
that CVSNT 2.5.03 assumed this for 'cvs watch' but 2.5.04 didn't
(because otherwise it was impossible to have a watch that wasn't a
readonly watch).

Regards,


Arthur Barrett
Product Manager



------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Let Crystal Reports handle the reporting - Free Crystal Reports 2008 30-Day 
trial. Simplify your report design, integration and deployment - and focus on 
what you do best, core application coding. Discover what's new with 
Crystal Reports now.  http://p.sf.net/sfu/bobj-july