Re: they won't allow you to use facts to embarrass them
"Keith J. Schultz" <[email protected]>
| Newsgroups | gmane.culture.literature.e-books.gutenberg.volunteers |
|---|---|
| Message-ID | <[email protected]> |
Hi All, Well, back in the Plain Vanilla days, if I remember correctly: 1 No. 2 Yes. 3 No Because the text was done differently. Furthermore, correction to a particular version was made to that version and a new revision was released. Today, the situation is somewhat more complex as the amount of information – formatting is greater. So 2, would be the way to go, also. Yet, if one just corrected the original submission( no idea how that could be done) then just a revision bump should be done. As to the credit line, just use corrections submitted by e.g BB. This would not imply a direct interaction between the original submitter and the corrector. regards Keith. Am 18.11.2012 um 20:30 schrieb [email protected]: > > moreover, i have created a clean version of the same edition > that jim used. so imagine that i am going to submit it to p.g., > along with the pagescans, to create a better overall package... > > this is the question for jim. > > what should p.g. do with my submission? > > 1. reject it. > > 2. put it under a new number. > > 3. accept it, and overwrite jim's edition with mine, complete > with a new credit-line mentioning "a volunteer", but no name. > (i would not take a joint credit-line, because that might imply > we'd worked together; and likely neither would jim, probably. > it would be acceptable to me if the credit-line got _deleted_.) > jim's flawed version could be stored in the "old" subdirectory, > because hey, nobody ever looks inside those anyway, do they? > > anyone else is invited to chip in their opinion as well, but i am > especially interested in jim's thoughts. and, if he makes a post > before thanksgiving, i will consider it in my deliberations about > whether or not, after thanksgiving weekend, i will indeed make > a submission to p.g. of a corrected edition of jim's "huck finn". _______________________________________________ gutvol-d mailing list gutvol-d-4LCm/o+qPMZ96Xl/[email protected] http://lists.pglaf.org/mailman/listinfo/gutvol-d