Islams New Voices See Faith with Critical Eye

Islam's new voices see faith with critical eye 
Scholars, activists favor democracy, gender equality 
Don Lattin, Chronicle Religion Writer
Monday, January 26, 2004 
©2004 San Francisco Chronicle | Feedback | FAQ 

URL: sfgate.com/article.cgi?file=/c/a/2004/01/26/MNGP84HMA01.DTL 

In the aftermath of Sept. 11, Muslim scholar Omid Safi found himself mouthing 
a
well-worn defense of his faith. 

"Islam is a religion of peace," he would say. "These people (the terrorists)
have nothing to do with Islam.'' 

But it didn't take long for Safi to acknowledge -- first to himself and then 
to
other Muslims offering the same sound bite -- that they were not really 
telling
the truth, or at least not telling the whole story. 

Long before the attacks on the World Trade Center and the Pentagon, Safi and
other Muslim spokesmen realized there was a growing, worldwide network of
Muslim terrorists killing in the name of Allah. They also knew that the 
rights
of women and non-Muslims were being routinely denied by Islamic regimes such 
as
the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia. 

"We have our fanatics just like everyone else,'' said Safi, an assistant
professor of Islamic Studies at Colgate University in Hamilton, N.Y. "We have
to take a stand against Saudi-infected extremism.'' 

Safi is among a small but growing movement of Islamic scholars and activists
calling themselves "progressive Muslims." They include gay Muslims, peace and
justice advocates, feminists advocating gender equality and Muslims working 
to
improve Islamic relations with Jews and people of other faiths. 

Islam, like other religions, changes at a glacial pace. Nevertheless,
progressive Muslims at several California mosques see a significant shift.
Mosques are becoming more democratic and less reliant on the sometimes 
extreme
views of imported sheikhs and imams. 

"They used to be given carte blanche authority,'' said Salam al-Marayati, the
executive director of the Muslim Public Affairs Council and a leading member 
of
the Islamic Society of Southern California. "Now we take a more critical view
of Muslim leadership. We are not blindly obedient.'' 

At the same time, women are starting to find a voice in the male- dominated
world of Islamic scholars, whose interpretations of the Koran often dictate 
how
Muslims practice their faith. 

"There are more women, but not enough,'' said al-Marayati. 

Kecia Ali, a research associate in the Women's Program in Religion Studies at
Harvard Divinity School, said progressive Muslims are not asking for major
changes in Islamic religious practice. 

"We're not looking to stop fasting during Ramadan or praying five times a
day,'' she said. "We are not even opposing segregation of the sexes during
prayer. But we will raise the issue of how women are given the inferior 
places
for prayer in many mosques.'' 

Leaders of the progressive movement say they are not questioning the basic
authority of the Koran, the Muslim scriptures revealed to the Prophet 
Mohammed
in the seventh century. But they do challenge some early interpretations used
to justify strict forms of Islamic law, especially as it relates to women,
Jews, "unbelievers" and criminal justice. 

Ebrahim Moosa, a professor of Islamic studies at Duke University, said 
Muslims
who think every line in the Koran must be implemented as law have a 
superficial
understanding of the faith. Much of the Koran, he said, is allegorical, and
must be looked at in its historical context. 

"People read a verse that says 'chop off the hand of a thief' and get all
passionate about it,'' he said. 

Moosa, Safi and Ali are all contributors to the manifesto of the new 
movement,
a book of essays titled "Progressive Muslims -- On Justice, Gender and
Equality,'' published last year by Oneworld Publications. 

"It's a delicate balancing act,'' said Ali. "We have to both defend Islam
against virulent stereotypes and offer a critique that acknowledges the
oppressive practices and ideas within Islam.'' 

One of the most radical calls for change comes from Irshad Manji, the 
Canadian
author of "The Trouble with Islam -- A Muslim's Call for Reform in Her 
Faith.''


Manji, 35, said Islam needs to "give a new generation of Muslims permission 
to
think.'' 

"Muslims in the West are hybrids, and we resent being asked to choose between
Islam and the West,'' said Manji, who was recently in San Francisco to 
promote
her book. "We are living in a new world.'' 

Manji, a self-described "liberal Muslim,'' is also a lesbian and very
media-savvy. She has hosted two Canadian TV shows, "QueerTelevision'' and 
"Big
Ideas,'' a TVOntario program aimed at college students. She appeared in The
Chronicle's newsroom last week with a female driver, a bald bodyguard and a
forceful but flexible attitude. 

"I'm openly gay, but not arrogantly gay,'' Manji said. "I acknowledge that my
(lesbian) relationship might not be OK with Allah.'' 

Among the labels applied to the telegenic Canadian are "Osama bin Laden's 
worst
nightmare'' and "a female Salman Rushdie.'' 

Rushdie, the celebrated British author, lived for nearly 10 years under a
kill-on-sight fatwa issued by Iran's late Ayatollah Khomeini, who was 
offended
by Rushdie's 1989 novel "Satanic Verses." Manji said she has been the target 
of
"concrete threats via e-mail'' but knows of no fatwa issued against her. 

"Rushdie's book was fiction, and the five pages that were controversial were
from a dream sequence,'' she said. 

In her book, Manji accuses her fellow Muslims of being "spiritually
infantile.'' 

"Muslims were imposing martial law and bludgeoning each other's freedoms 
before
European colonialism took off,'' she writes. "To this day, Muslims use the
white man as a weapon of mass distraction -- a distraction from the fact that
we've never needed the 'oppressive' West to oppress our own.'' 

Manji argues that Muslims need to foster "the spirit of inquiry'' and a
"culture of tolerance'' in the practice of their faith, while turning away 
from
religious fundamentalism and spiritual tyranny. "What must be stripped from
Islam is its desert strain of tribalism, which takes the act of closing ranks
to a crushing level,'' she writes. 

Manji's ideas got a mixed reaction last week from Bay Area Muslims. "I don't
buy her argument about there being no discourse in Islam,'' said Helei 
Omaria,
executive director of the Council on American-Islamic Relations in Santa 
Clara.
"It's a big world, and there are a lot of opinions. She is just a drop in the
bucket.'' 

Another leader in the South Bay Muslim community, Hisham Abdullah, said Manji
and other liberal reformers have raised some valid issues. 

"People are not as open to debate and re-evaluation as has been the case
historically in Islam,'' said Abdullah, who works in the pharmaceutical
industry and holds a degree in Islamic law. "There is intimidation of the
masses. People tend to say that the right way is the strictest way.'' 

Maha El Genaidi, who does community relations work for the Bay Area Islamic
Network, said she had not read Manji's book, but didn't think there was
anything that new about the message. 

"The so-called progressives aren't saying anything all that different from
traditional scholars,'' she said. "There has always been a diversity of
interpretations in Islam.'' 

But Souleiman Ghali, president of the San Francisco Islamic Society, said he
agrees with many of the points raised by Islam's in-house critics. 

"We need to open up and listen and learn how to take criticism,'' Ghali said.
"The danger is not discussing these things.'' 

Ghali said he has raised the issue of women's rights in his Tenderloin 
mosque,
but often meets resistance from "the immigrant community and traditional 
people
from the Middle East.'' 

"Saudi Arabia has had the money and the leverage to spread their version of
Islam in America,'' he added. "Many people have adopted that version of
theology.'' 

Several leaders in the progressive movement are -- ironically -- looking to
Iran as a possible model for a new kind of Islamic society. Opposition to the
authoritarian power of Muslim clerics in that Islamic state has in recent 
years
sparked widespread calls for secular reform. 

"Iran provides the best hope for progressive Islam,'' Manji said. 

Moosa, the Duke professor, agreed. 

"The shortest way to Islamic liberalism,'' he said, "is through Islamic
fundamentalism.'' 

E-mail Don Lattin at [email protected].