Re: The vulcan mind melt

Alan,

On Sun, Oct 26, 2003 at 05:29:48PM -0500, Alan DeKok wrote:
> 
>   My reason for joining this group, and agreeing to coordinate the
> efforts, was so that I could coordinate a joint proposal.  If no one
> is willing to create a joint proposal, or work with others to create a
> joint proposal, then my recommendation is that the sub-group be
> disbanded.


just gimme a hint: What's wrong? Anything not OK with my effort 
to start a combined proposal? As I said, it is mostly incomplete
yet, but it is intended to cover all proposals existing so far, 
but to interpolate the differences. Even if it is just a beginning, 
you will see that this significantly differs from my own RMX proposal, 
it already contains the DRIP approach.

I currently don't understand why you complain that no one is 
willing to create a joint proposal. If this is not what I'm trying to 
do, just tell me what's wrong.

To get a combined proposal, we still need to discuss and decide some 
fundamental questions which I already addressed throughout the last 
days. Unfortunately, this is treated more like a religion, everyone
says "I believe in ...", and that's it. It's a bunch of different
opinions, but not yet a discussion or working group. But I still
believe we can get it forward.

I have already changed my mind after being convinced, and I hope 
others can do the same.


If not, just tell me, I then will work on RMX on my own.

regards
Hadmut