Re: WG Last call on: "Requirements For Adding Optical Support To GSMPv3"

Hi all,


Sundell, Kenneth [ERK:AA50:EXCH] wrote:
 > 7.1.2.
 > [5]->[4]
 > comment: so the question is: should GSMP acknowledge Events or not? what
 > is the requirement?

The requirement would one of the following.
1. Don't allow ReturnReceipt for events
or
2. Use a real TransactionId for events to make it possible to identify
    which controller has answered.

I prefer the first solution, but both would solve the problem.

 > 7.2.1
 > Missing chapter or has the numbering disappeared?

This is a mistake in chapter numbering...

 >
 > 7.4.1.
 > looses->loses
 > draft->[4]
 > comment: isn't the requirement here that [4] should specify how to
 > introduce an additional controller to an already existing partition?
 > Also since this is a requirement doc, should it suggest solutions?
 >
 > 7.5.
 > chapter relates to 7.1.2. could it be merged?

Absolutely.


 >
 > --
 >
 > avri doria wrote:
 >
 >> Hi,
 >>
 >> As was discussed at IETF53, as soon as the burst requirements were
 >> added to the
 >> Optical Support Requirements draft, it was going to be brought to the
 >> group for
 >> WG Last Call.  This draft has now be submitted with those changes.
 >>
 >>     Title        : Requirements For Adding Optical Support To GSMPv3
 >>     Author(s)    : G. Kullgren et al.
 >>     Filename    : draft-ietf-gsmp-reqs-03.txt
 >>     Pages        : 16
 >>     Date        : 2002-9-27
 >>     A URL for this Internet-Draft is:
 >> http://www.ietf.org/internet-drafts/draft-ietf-gsmp-reqs-03.txt
 >>
 >>
 >>
 >>
 >> The intention of this WG last call is towfold:
 >> - Are these the requirements we must meet support GMPLS in the next
 >> revision of the GSMP spec
 >> - Is this ID ready to be sent on to IESG for consideration as an
 >> Informational RFC
 >>
 >> The last call will last the customary 2 weeks, and is scheduled to end
 >> 15 Oct, 2002.
 >>
 >> Please read the draft and send commentd to this list.
 >>
 >> Thanks
 >>
 >> a.
 >>
 >> --
 >> Avri Doria
 >> wg co-chair
 >>
 >>
 >> _______________________________________________
 >> GSMP mailing list
 >> [email protected]
 >> https://www1.ietf.org/mailman/listinfo/gsmp
 >>
 >
 >
 > _______________________________________________
 > GSMP mailing list
 > [email protected]
 > https://www1.ietf.org/mailman/listinfo/gsmp
 >


-- 
------------------------------------------------------------------------
Georg Kullgren            Nortel Networks AB    [email protected]
System Architect          S:t Eriksgatan 115 A  Tel:   +46-8-50 88 36 18
Routing Architecture Lab  SE-113 85 Stockholm   Mobile: +46-703-14 36 18
ATI Strategic Protocols   Sweden                Fax:   +46-8-50 88 35 01