RE: mboned: draft-liu-magma-igmpv3-mldv2-lite-00.txt

I have a couple of comments only to this:

-------Original Message-----
> From: Dino Farinacci [mailto:[email protected]] 
>     Specific comments:
> 
>     1) Don't use the term ASM in the draft. Refer to 
> "Exclude(NULL)" as  
>        joining a (*,G) entry rather than a specific (Si,G) entry. Same
>        for the "Include(All)" case.

I would prefer to see, at least once in the beginning, that joining
(*,G) is equivalent to ASM. This makes it clear that IGMPv3/MLDv2 are
also usable for ASM, to potentially replace all previous versions of
IGMP and MLD.

Also, maybe I've missed something obvious, but clearly EXCLUDE(null)
means joining (*,G) like ASM. What does INCLUDE(null) mean? Below:

>       o  Current-State-Include, where when the source count 
> is non-zero, it
>          is the host joining the various (Si,G), where each 
> Si is in the source
>          list. When the source count is zero, the host is 
> joining (*,G).

implies it means the same thing as EXCLUDE(null). But logically, I don't
see that.

Bert