RE: CTP - a few comments on draft-ietf-seamoby-ctp-05.. .

Hi John,

I guess I haven't followed the discussion very closely,
Is the replacement of R flag with A flag an open issue yet?

How can the R flags for reliability be replaced with an 
acknowledge flag and expect that they do the same thing.

Madjid

-----Original Message-----
From: [email protected] [mailto:[email protected]]On Behalf Of
[email protected]
Sent: Friday, November 21, 2003 2:57 AM
To: [email protected]; [email protected]
Subject: RE: [Seamoby] CTP - a few comments on
draft-ietf-seamoby-ctp-05...


Hi,

Assigned issue 31: 
> Editorial:
> 
>     In section 2.5.2 Context Transfer Activate Acknowledge 
> (CTAA) Message:
> 
>         Reserved     Reserved for future use. Must be set to 
> zero by the MN.
>             >>could be changed with>>
>         Must be set to zero by the sender of CTAA Message, 
> i.e. pAR or nAR.
> 
>     In 2.5.3 Context Transfer Data (CTD) Message:
> 
>         A reliability flag, 'R'
>             >>could be changed with>>
>         An acknowlwdgement flag 'A'
> 
>         ...indicates whether a reply is required by nAR.
>             >>could be changed with>>
>         ...indicates whether a reply is required by pAR.
> 
>         Reserved   Reserved for future use.  Must be set to 
> zero by the MN.
>             >>could be changed with>>
>         Must be set to zero by the pAR.
> 
>         Perhaps move here the description of 'Elapsed Time' 
> which exists 
> in section 3...
> 
>     In section 2.5.4  Context Transfer Data Reply (CTDR) Message
> 
>         Reserved   Reserved for future use.  Must be set to 
> zero by the MN.
>             >>could be changed with>>
>         Must be set to zero by the nAR.
> 
>     In 2.5.5  Context Transfer Cancel (CTC) Message
> 
>         Reserved   Reserved for future use.  Must be set to 
> zero by the MN.
>             >>could be changed with>>
>         Must be set to zero by the nAR.
> 
>     In 2.5.6 Context Transfer Request (CT Request) Message
> 
>         Reserved   Reserved for future use.  Must be set to 
> zero by the MN.
>             >>could be changed with>>
>         Must be set to zero by the nAR.


_______________________________________________
Seamoby mailing list
[email protected]
https://www1.ietf.org/mailman/listinfo/seamoby