Proposal A Amendament (was: Re: Proposal -- Interpretation of DFSG on Artificial Intelligence (AI) Models

The issue is also discussed here:
https://lwn.net/Articles/1019028/

A better wording goes:
s/open source license/DFSG-compatible license/g

It is fixed in the git repo:
https://salsa.debian.org/lumin/gr-ai-dfsg/-/commit/9496f9fb6405db5a99fff1672cd4bad66c925c24

The proposal after amendament:

===============================================================================
Proposal A: "AI models released under DFSG-compatible license license without
            original training data or program" are not seen as DFSG-compliant.
===============================================================================

The "AI models released under DFSG-compatible license license without original
training data or program", a particular type of files as explained above, are
not seen as DFSG-compliant. Hence, they can not be included in the "main"
section of the Debian archive. This proposal does not specify whether the
"non-free" section of Debian archive can include those files.


On Mon, 2025-05-05 at 13:22 -0600, Sam Hartman wrote:
> > > > > > "M" == M Zhou <[email protected]> writes:
> ===================================
>     M> Proposal A: "AI models released under open source license without
>     M> original training data or program" are not seen as
>     M> DFSG-compliant.
>     M> ===============================================================================
> 
>     M> The "AI models released under open source license without
>     M> original training data or program", a particular type of files as
> 
> 
> I find the use of Open Source License in a Debian context problematic.
> The DFSG is not the OSD, and we should care whether a license is DFSG
> free not OSI approved.
> 
> I hope that you would be willing to accept an amendment to replace all
> uses of open source in your proposal.

-----BEGIN PGP SIGNATURE-----
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=uO5v
-----END PGP SIGNATURE-----