Re: Third update of the ballot option: Call the Free Software community to develop Free AI.

--v0NccwS9KNxI73GO
Content-Type: text/plain; charset=utf-8
Content-Disposition: inline
Content-Transfer-Encoding: quoted-printable

On Thu, Jul 30, 2026 at 07:04:29AM +0900, Charles Plessy wrote:
> Marc, Tobias, thank you for writing your ballots.  However they both
> have the same critical flaw: they are written with AI assistance.=20
> (=E2=80=A6)
> Would you consider replacing the current versions with
> human-edited versions of your drafts or notes before you used AI ?

Thank you for the suggestion.

Be assured that I invested a considerable amount of time and thought
into crafting this proposal=C2=B9. It went through multiple iterations befo=
re
arriving at the current version, which reflects my own judgment and the
outcome I wanted to achieve.  =20

I chose to disclose my use of an LLM because I believe transparency is
important, especially in the context of this GR. At the same time, I
consider this proposal to be a practical demonstration of one of the
central points I have made elsewhere in this discussion: for me, an LLM
can act as a drafting and language-assistance tool without replacing my
own ideas, reasoning, or responsibility for the final text.

For that reason, I do not intend to replace the current version=C2=B2 with =
one
prepared through a different drafting process. I would instead refer to
the arguments I made earlier in this subthread:

https://lists.debian.org/debian-vote/2026/07/msg00185.html
https://lists.debian.org/debian-vote/2026/07/msg00233.html


=C2=B9 Shameless plug: the proposal is still looking for seconders.
=C2=B2 https://lists.debian.org/debian-vote/2026/07/msg00343.html

--=20
tobi

--v0NccwS9KNxI73GO
Content-Type: application/pgp-signature; name=signature.asc

-----BEGIN PGP SIGNATURE-----
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=S0jA
-----END PGP SIGNATURE-----

--v0NccwS9KNxI73GO--