Re: newsgroup subscribe fetches wrong messages

Hi,

I dont have any special setup. my nntp is the 1und1 - news server, "news.online.de".
i looked a little closer into this problem. it does not seem to affect ALL of the messages of a subscribed newsgroup. i subscribed to "uk.media films" and most of the messages were (correctly) fetched from "uk.media.films". i found one message that accidently made its way in there:

--------------
Subject: Please help me Identify this film 
From: Herbert Moriarty
-------------

converted itself to this while opening:

---------------------------------------------
Path: news.online.de!schlund.de!newsfeed01.sul.t-online.de!t-online.de!newsfeed.vmunix.org!newsfeed.eunet.at!newsfeed.eunet.at!news-hub.siol.net!bnewsfeed00.bru.ops.eu.uu.net!bnewsifeed00.bru.ops.eu.uu.net!lnewspost00.lnd.ops.eu.uu.net!emea.uu.net!read.news.fr.uu.net!not-for-mail
Message-ID: <[email protected]>
Date: Wed, 12 Mar 2003 12:07:23 +0100
From: Sylvain Donnet <[email protected]>
User-Agent: Mozilla/5.0 (Windows; U; Windows NT 5.0; en-US; rv:1.0rc2) Gecko/20020510
X-Accept-Language: en-us, en
MIME-Version: 1.0
Newsgroups: fr.misc.droit
Subject: Re: Pb de bail 3/6/9
References: <[email protected]> <[email protected]> <[email protected]> <[email protected]> <[email protected]> <[email protected]>
Content-Type: text/plain; charset=ISO-8859-1; format=flowed
Content-Transfer-Encoding: 8bit
Lines: 8
NNTP-Posting-Host: 194.98.155.31
X-Trace: 1047467244 read.news.fr.uu.net 29493 194.98.155.31
X-Complaints-To: [email protected]
Xref: news.online.de fr.misc.droit:221260

Merci de toutes ces informations. Je vais prendre contact avec le 
proprio pour une discussion à l'amiable. Mais j'aurais cependant voulu 
savoir si le fait qu'il ait "enterré" le sujet, et qu'il ne m'ait pas 
informé du problème sur la forme constitue ou pas un dol, tel que j'ai 
vu cela dans ce même forum il y a longtemps.

Sylvain
---------------------------------------------

the excerpt of logfile syl.log (made like this: sylpheed_d >syl.log)
shows the following:

d:\dev\proj\sylpheed-claws\src\folderview.c:1738:Folder uk.media.films is selected
d:\dev\proj\sylpheed-claws\src\folder.c:1043:Scanning folder uk.media.films for cache changes.
[12:44:23] NNTP> MODE READER
[12:44:23] NNTP< 200 news.online.de InterNetNews NNRP server INN 2.3.5 ready (posting ok).
[12:44:23] NNTP> GROUP uk.media.films
[12:44:23] NNTP< 211 23 21525 21583 uk.media.films
d:\dev\proj\sylpheed-claws\src\news.c:1086:removing old messages from 21525 to 21583 in E:\daten\sylpheed-claws\.sylpheed\newscache\news.online.de\uk.media.films
d:\dev\proj\sylpheed-claws\src\msgcache.c:208:	No cache file
d:\dev\proj\sylpheed-claws\src\folder.c:1043:Scanning folder uk.media.films for cache changes.
[12:44:23] NNTP> GROUP uk.media.films
[12:44:23] NNTP< 211 23 21525 21583 uk.media.films
d:\dev\proj\sylpheed-claws\src\news.c:1086:removing old messages from 21525 to 21583 in E:\daten\sylpheed-claws\.sylpheed\newscache\news.online.de\uk.media.films
d:\dev\proj\sylpheed-claws\src\folder.c:1122:Remembered message 21525 for fetching
d:\dev\proj\sylpheed-claws\src\folder.c:1122:Remembered message 21526 for fetching
d:\dev\proj\sylpheed-claws\src\folder.c:1122:Remembered message 21527 for fetching
d:\dev\proj\sylpheed-claws\src\folder.c:1122:Remembered message 21528 for fetching
d:\dev\proj\sylpheed-claws\src\folder.c:1122:Remembered message 21529 for fetching
d:\dev\proj\sylpheed-claws\src\folder.c:1122:Remembered message 21530 for fetching
d:\dev\proj\sylpheed-claws\src\folder.c:1122:Remembered message 21531 for fetching
d:\dev\proj\sylpheed-claws\src\folder.c:1122:Remembered message 21532 for fetching
d:\dev\proj\sylpheed-claws\src\folder.c:1122:Remembered message 21533 for fetching
d:\dev\proj\sylpheed-claws\src\folder.c:1122:Remembered message 21534 for fetching
d:\dev\proj\sylpheed-claws\src\folder.c:1122:Remembered message 21535 for fetching
d:\dev\proj\sylpheed-claws\src\folder.c:1122:Remembered message 21536 for fetching
d:\dev\proj\sylpheed-claws\src\folder.c:1122:Remembered message 21537 for fetching
d:\dev\proj\sylpheed-claws\src\folder.c:1122:Remembered message 21538 for fetching
d:\dev\proj\sylpheed-claws\src\folder.c:1122:Remembered message 21539 for fetching
d:\dev\proj\sylpheed-claws\src\folder.c:1122:Remembered message 21540 for fetching
d:\dev\proj\sylpheed-claws\src\folder.c:1122:Remembered message 21541 for fetching
d:\dev\proj\sylpheed-claws\src\folder.c:1122:Remembered message 21542 for fetching
d:\dev\proj\sylpheed-claws\src\folder.c:1122:Remembered message 21543 for fetching
d:\dev\proj\sylpheed-claws\src\folder.c:1122:Remembered message 21544 for fetching
d:\dev\proj\sylpheed-claws\src\folder.c:1122:Remembered message 21545 for fetching
d:\dev\proj\sylpheed-claws\src\folder.c:1122:Remembered message 21546 for fetching
d:\dev\proj\sylpheed-claws\src\folder.c:1122:Remembered message 21547 for fetching
d:\dev\proj\sylpheed-claws\src\folder.c:1122:Remembered message 21548 for fetching
d:\dev\proj\sylpheed-claws\src\folder.c:1122:Remembered message 21549 for fetching
d:\dev\proj\sylpheed-claws\src\folder.c:1122:Remembered message 21550 for fetching
d:\dev\proj\sylpheed-claws\src\folder.c:1122:Remembered message 21551 for fetching
d:\dev\proj\sylpheed-claws\src\folder.c:1122:Remembered message 21552 for fetching
d:\dev\proj\sylpheed-claws\src\folder.c:1122:Remembered message 21553 for fetching
d:\dev\proj\sylpheed-claws\src\folder.c:1122:Remembered message 21554 for fetching
d:\dev\proj\sylpheed-claws\src\folder.c:1122:Remembered message 21555 for fetching
d:\dev\proj\sylpheed-claws\src\folder.c:1122:Remembered message 21556 for fetching
d:\dev\proj\sylpheed-claws\src\folder.c:1122:Remembered message 21557 for fetching
d:\dev\proj\sylpheed-claws\src\folder.c:1122:Remembered message 21558 for fetching
d:\dev\proj\sylpheed-claws\src\folder.c:1122:Remembered message 21559 for fetching
d:\dev\proj\sylpheed-claws\src\folder.c:1122:Remembered message 21560 for fetching
d:\dev\proj\sylpheed-claws\src\folder.c:1122:Remembered message 21561 for fetching
d:\dev\proj\sylpheed-claws\src\folder.c:1122:Remembered message 21562 for fetching
d:\dev\proj\sylpheed-claws\src\folder.c:1122:Remembered message 21563 for fetching
d:\dev\proj\sylpheed-claws\src\folder.c:1122:Remembered message 21564 for fetching
d:\dev\proj\sylpheed-claws\src\folder.c:1122:Remembered message 21565 for fetching
d:\dev\proj\sylpheed-claws\src\folder.c:1122:Remembered message 21566 for fetching
d:\dev\proj\sylpheed-claws\src\folder.c:1122:Remembered message 21567 for fetching
d:\dev\proj\sylpheed-claws\src\folder.c:1122:Remembered message 21568 for fetching
d:\dev\proj\sylpheed-claws\src\folder.c:1122:Remembered message 21569 for fetching
d:\dev\proj\sylpheed-claws\src\folder.c:1122:Remembered message 21570 for fetching
d:\dev\proj\sylpheed-claws\src\folder.c:1122:Remembered message 21571 for fetching
d:\dev\proj\sylpheed-claws\src\folder.c:1122:Remembered message 21572 for fetching
d:\dev\proj\sylpheed-claws\src\folder.c:1122:Remembered message 21573 for fetching
d:\dev\proj\sylpheed-claws\src\folder.c:1122:Remembered message 21574 for fetching
d:\dev\proj\sylpheed-claws\src\folder.c:1122:Remembered message 21575 for fetching
d:\dev\proj\sylpheed-claws\src\folder.c:1122:Remembered message 21576 for fetching
d:\dev\proj\sylpheed-claws\src\folder.c:1122:Remembered message 21577 for fetching
d:\dev\proj\sylpheed-claws\src\folder.c:1122:Remembered message 21578 for fetching
d:\dev\proj\sylpheed-claws\src\folder.c:1122:Remembered message 21579 for fetching
d:\dev\proj\sylpheed-claws\src\folder.c:1122:Remembered message 21580 for fetching
d:\dev\proj\sylpheed-claws\src\folder.c:1122:Remembered message 21581 for fetching
d:\dev\proj\sylpheed-claws\src\folder.c:1122:Remembered message 21582 for fetching
d:\dev\proj\sylpheed-claws\src\folder.c:1122:Remembered message 21583 for fetching
[12:44:23] NNTP> XOVER 21525-21583
[12:44:24] NNTP< 224 21525-21583 fields follow
[12:44:24] NNTP> XHDR to 21525-21583
[12:44:24] NNTP< 221 to fields follow
[12:44:24] NNTP> XHDR cc 21525-21583
[12:44:24] NNTP< 221 cc fields follow
d:\dev\proj\sylpheed-claws\src\msgcache.c:80:Cache size: 1 messages, 285 byte
d:\dev\proj\sylpheed-claws\src\msgcache.c:80:Cache size: 2 messages, 535 byte
d:\dev\proj\sylpheed-claws\src\msgcache.c:80:Cache size: 3 messages, 919 byte
d:\dev\proj\sylpheed-claws\src\msgcache.c:80:Cache size: 4 messages, 1410 byte
d:\dev\proj\sylpheed-claws\src\msgcache.c:80:Cache size: 5 messages, 1951 byte
d:\dev\proj\sylpheed-claws\src\msgcache.c:80:Cache size: 6 messages, 2314 byte
d:\dev\proj\sylpheed-claws\src\msgcache.c:80:Cache size: 7 messages, 2598 byte
d:\dev\proj\sylpheed-claws\src\msgcache.c:80:Cache size: 8 messages, 2989 byte
d:\dev\proj\sylpheed-claws\src\msgcache.c:80:Cache size: 9 messages, 3374 byte
d:\dev\proj\sylpheed-claws\src\msgcache.c:80:Cache size: 10 messages, 3753 byte
d:\dev\proj\sylpheed-claws\src\msgcache.c:80:Cache size: 11 messages, 4181 byte
d:\dev\proj\sylpheed-claws\src\msgcache.c:80:Cache size: 12 messages, 4479 byte
d:\dev\proj\sylpheed-claws\src\msgcache.c:80:Cache size: 13 messages, 4786 byte
d:\dev\proj\sylpheed-claws\src\msgcache.c:80:Cache size: 14 messages, 5088 byte
d:\dev\proj\sylpheed-claws\src\msgcache.c:80:Cache size: 15 messages, 5385 byte
d:\dev\proj\sylpheed-claws\src\msgcache.c:80:Cache size: 16 messages, 5626 byte
d:\dev\proj\sylpheed-claws\src\msgcache.c:80:Cache size: 17 messages, 5905 byte
d:\dev\proj\sylpheed-claws\src\msgcache.c:80:Cache size: 18 messages, 6241 byte
d:\dev\proj\sylpheed-claws\src\msgcache.c:80:Cache size: 19 messages, 6549 byte
d:\dev\proj\sylpheed-claws\src\msgcache.c:80:Cache size: 20 messages, 6950 byte
d:\dev\proj\sylpheed-claws\src\msgcache.c:80:Cache size: 21 messages, 7235 byte
d:\dev\proj\sylpheed-claws\src\msgcache.c:80:Cache size: 22 messages, 7583 byte
d:\dev\proj\sylpheed-claws\src\msgcache.c:80:Cache size: 23 messages, 7865 byte
d:\dev\proj\sylpheed-claws\src\msgcache.c:288:Mark file not found.
d:\dev\proj\sylpheed-claws\src\folder.c:1332:Total cache memory usage: 5459174
d:\dev\proj\sylpheed-claws\src\folder.c:1337:Trying to free cache memory
d:\dev\proj\sylpheed-claws\src\folder.c:1306:Cache unused time: 222 (Expire time: 900)
d:\dev\proj\sylpheed-claws\src\folder.c:1306:Cache unused time: 273 (Expire time: 900)
d:\dev\proj\sylpheed-claws\src\folder.c:1306:Cache unused time: 273 (Expire time: 900)
d:\dev\proj\sylpheed-claws\src\folder.c:1306:Cache unused time: 273 (Expire time: 900)
d:\dev\proj\sylpheed-claws\src\folder.c:1306:Cache unused time: 273 (Expire time: 900)
d:\dev\proj\sylpheed-claws\src\folder.c:1306:Cache unused time: 273 (Expire time: 900)
d:\dev\proj\sylpheed-claws\src\folder.c:1306:Cache unused time: 272 (Expire time: 900)
d:\dev\proj\sylpheed-claws\src\folder.c:1306:Cache unused time: 272 (Expire time: 900)
d:\dev\proj\sylpheed-claws\src\folder.c:1306:Cache unused time: 272 (Expire time: 900)
d:\dev\proj\sylpheed-claws\src\folder.c:1306:Cache unused time: 272 (Expire time: 900)
d:\dev\proj\sylpheed-claws\src\folder.c:1306:Cache unused time: 272 (Expire time: 900)
d:\dev\proj\sylpheed-claws\src\folder.c:1306:Cache unused time: 272 (Expire time: 900)
d:\dev\proj\sylpheed-claws\src\folder.c:1306:Cache unused time: 272 (Expire time: 900)
d:\dev\proj\sylpheed-claws\src\folder.c:1306:Cache unused time: 273 (Expire time: 900)
d:\dev\proj\sylpheed-claws\src\folder.c:1306:Cache unused time: 272 (Expire time: 900)
d:\dev\proj\sylpheed-claws\src\folder.c:1306:Cache unused time: 272 (Expire time: 900)
d:\dev\proj\sylpheed-claws\src\folder.c:1306:Cache unused time: 272 (Expire time: 900)
d:\dev\proj\sylpheed-claws\src\folder.c:1306:Cache unused time: 272 (Expire time: 900)
d:\dev\proj\sylpheed-claws\src\folder.c:1306:Cache unused time: 272 (Expire time: 900)
d:\dev\proj\sylpheed-claws\src\folder.c:1306:Cache unused time: 272 (Expire time: 900)
d:\dev\proj\sylpheed-claws\src\folder.c:1306:Cache unused time: 272 (Expire time: 900)
d:\dev\proj\sylpheed-claws\src\folder.c:1306:Cache unused time: 271 (Expire time: 900)
d:\dev\proj\sylpheed-claws\src\folder.c:1306:Cache unused time: 267 (Expire time: 900)
d:\dev\proj\sylpheed-claws\src\folder.c:1306:Cache unused time: 266 (Expire time: 900)
d:\dev\proj\sylpheed-claws\src\folder.c:1306:Cache unused time: 265 (Expire time: 900)
d:\dev\proj\sylpheed-claws\src\folder.c:1306:Cache unused time: 263 (Expire time: 900)
d:\dev\proj\sylpheed-claws\src\folder.c:1306:Cache unused time: 262 (Expire time: 900)
d:\dev\proj\sylpheed-claws\src\folder.c:1306:Cache unused time: 262 (Expire time: 900)
d:\dev\proj\sylpheed-claws\src\folder.c:1306:Cache unused time: 264 (Expire time: 900)
d:\dev\proj\sylpheed-claws\src\folder.c:1306:Cache unused time: 263 (Expire time: 900)
d:\dev\proj\sylpheed-claws\src\folder.c:1306:Cache unused time: 85 (Expire time: 900)
d:\dev\proj\sylpheed-claws\src\folder.c:1306:Cache unused time: 0 (Expire time: 900)
d:\dev\proj\sylpheed-claws\src\summaryview.c:875:Durchsuche Ablage (uk.media.films)...
d:\dev\proj\sylpheed-claws\src\summaryview.c:2147:	Setting summary from message data...d:\dev\proj\sylpheed-claws\src\addressbook.c:3703:addressbook_load_completion
d:\dev\proj\sylpheed-claws\src\addressbook.c:3761:addressbook_load_completion... done
d:\dev\proj\sylpheed-claws\src\addr_compl.c:207:start_address_completion ref count 1
d:\dev\proj\sylpheed-claws\src\addr_compl.c:467:end_address_completion ref count 0
d:\dev\proj\sylpheed-claws\src\summaryview.c:2230:done.
d:\dev\proj\sylpheed-claws\src\summaryview.c:2233:	msgid hash table size = 23
d:\dev\proj\sylpheed-claws\src\summaryview.c:2235:	subject hash table size = 0
d:\dev\proj\sylpheed-claws\src\summaryview.c:1048:
d:\dev\proj\sylpheed-claws\src\folder.c:1332:Total cache memory usage: 5459174
d:\dev\proj\sylpheed-claws\src\folder.c:1337:Trying to free cache memory
d:\dev\proj\sylpheed-claws\src\folder.c:1306:Cache unused time: 222 (Expire time: 900)
d:\dev\proj\sylpheed-claws\src\folder.c:1306:Cache unused time: 273 (Expire time: 900)
d:\dev\proj\sylpheed-claws\src\folder.c:1306:Cache unused time: 273 (Expire time: 900)
d:\dev\proj\sylpheed-claws\src\folder.c:1306:Cache unused time: 273 (Expire time: 900)
d:\dev\proj\sylpheed-claws\src\folder.c:1306:Cache unused time: 273 (Expire time: 900)
d:\dev\proj\sylpheed-claws\src\folder.c:1306:Cache unused time: 273 (Expire time: 900)
d:\dev\proj\sylpheed-claws\src\folder.c:1306:Cache unused time: 272 (Expire time: 900)
d:\dev\proj\sylpheed-claws\src\folder.c:1306:Cache unused time: 272 (Expire time: 900)
d:\dev\proj\sylpheed-claws\src\folder.c:1306:Cache unused time: 272 (Expire time: 900)
d:\dev\proj\sylpheed-claws\src\folder.c:1306:Cache unused time: 272 (Expire time: 900)
d:\dev\proj\sylpheed-claws\src\folder.c:1306:Cache unused time: 272 (Expire time: 900)
d:\dev\proj\sylpheed-claws\src\folder.c:1306:Cache unused time: 272 (Expire time: 900)
d:\dev\proj\sylpheed-claws\src\folder.c:1306:Cache unused time: 272 (Expire time: 900)
d:\dev\proj\sylpheed-claws\src\folder.c:1306:Cache unused time: 273 (Expire time: 900)
d:\dev\proj\sylpheed-claws\src\folder.c:1306:Cache unused time: 272 (Expire time: 900)
d:\dev\proj\sylpheed-claws\src\folder.c:1306:Cache unused time: 272 (Expire time: 900)
d:\dev\proj\sylpheed-claws\src\folder.c:1306:Cache unused time: 272 (Expire time: 900)
d:\dev\proj\sylpheed-claws\src\folder.c:1306:Cache unused time: 272 (Expire time: 900)
d:\dev\proj\sylpheed-claws\src\folder.c:1306:Cache unused time: 272 (Expire time: 900)
d:\dev\proj\sylpheed-claws\src\folder.c:1306:Cache unused time: 272 (Expire time: 900)
d:\dev\proj\sylpheed-claws\src\folder.c:1306:Cache unused time: 272 (Expire time: 900)
d:\dev\proj\sylpheed-claws\src\folder.c:1306:Cache unused time: 271 (Expire time: 900)
d:\dev\proj\sylpheed-claws\src\folder.c:1306:Cache unused time: 267 (Expire time: 900)
d:\dev\proj\sylpheed-claws\src\folder.c:1306:Cache unused time: 266 (Expire time: 900)
d:\dev\proj\sylpheed-claws\src\folder.c:1306:Cache unused time: 265 (Expire time: 900)
d:\dev\proj\sylpheed-claws\src\folder.c:1306:Cache unused time: 263 (Expire time: 900)
d:\dev\proj\sylpheed-claws\src\folder.c:1306:Cache unused time: 262 (Expire time: 900)
d:\dev\proj\sylpheed-claws\src\folder.c:1306:Cache unused time: 262 (Expire time: 900)
d:\dev\proj\sylpheed-claws\src\folder.c:1306:Cache unused time: 264 (Expire time: 900)
d:\dev\proj\sylpheed-claws\src\folder.c:1306:Cache unused time: 263 (Expire time: 900)
d:\dev\proj\sylpheed-claws\src\folder.c:1306:Cache unused time: 85 (Expire time: 900)
d:\dev\proj\sylpheed-claws\src\news.c:386:getting article 21581...
[12:44:27] NNTP> ARTICLE 21581
[12:44:28] NNTP< 220 21581 <[email protected]> article
d:\dev\proj\sylpheed-claws\src\news.c:647:Message-Id = [email protected], num = 21581
d:\dev\proj\sylpheed-claws\src\procmsg.c:1482:Unsetting flags for message 21581 in folder uk.media.films
d:\dev\proj\sylpheed-claws\src\procmsg.c:500:Mark file not found.
d:\dev\proj\sylpheed-claws\src\news.c:386:getting article 21525...
[12:44:31] NNTP> ARTICLE 21525
[12:44:31] NNTP< 220 21525 <[email protected]> article
d:\dev\proj\sylpheed-claws\src\news.c:647:Message-Id = [email protected], num = 21525
d:\dev\proj\sylpheed-claws\src\procmsg.c:1482:Unsetting flags for message 21525 in folder uk.media.films
d:\dev\proj\sylpheed-claws\src\alertpanel.c:243:Creating alert panel dialog...
d:\dev\proj\sylpheed-claws\src\alertpanel.c:85:return value = 0
d:\dev\proj\sylpheed-claws\src\folder.c:1043:Scanning folder queue for cache changes.
d:\dev\proj\sylpheed-claws\src\mh.c:213:mh_get_last_num(): Scanning queue ...
current dir: e:\daten\sylpheed_daten\queue





On Sun, 30 Mar 2003 12:13:11 +0200
Thorsten Maerz <[email protected]> wrote:

> 
> Hi handlanger,
> 
> On Sun, 30 Mar 2003 11:33:36 +0200 handlanger mailing <[email protected]> wrote:
> 
> > i am not at all sure that this problem is sylpheed related but during the
> > rare occasions that i was using newsgroup this never happened before: I tried
> > to subscribe a newsgroup in sylpheed, "de.rec.film.misc". the messages were
> > fetched from the server, subject lines look as if the people in the newsgroup
> > are talking about films. when i open the message (does not matter if as
> > previe or "really" open it), a different message shows up. The messages are
> > neither from the requested newsgroup nor does the subject match what was
> > shown in the overview.
> 
> I never heard / saw this, though I follow about 10 groups very regularly.
> Can you take a look at the output from the debug version (search the
> claws/win32 homepage for "debug") and the log window (from the tools menu)
> if there is a wrong group selected or anything similar?
> 
> You can also check the updated claws23-1 (also needs updated DLL pack),
> there was at least a change in claws11 regarding the display of newsgroup
> folders and headers.
> 
> Do you have any special setup (e.g. using Hamster, etc.)?
> 
> Regards,
> -- 
> Thorsten Maerz          <[email protected]>
> Sylpheed-claws/Win32:   http://claws-w32.sf.net
> 


-------------------------------------------------------
This SF.net email is sponsored by:
The Definitive IT and Networking Event. Be There!
NetWorld+Interop Las Vegas 2003 -- Register today!
http://ads.sourceforge.net/cgi-bin/redirect.pl?keyn0001en