Re: Debian GNU/Hurd

Jonathan Haack <jonathan-z41ulFnQs1aKQSNuG+CHvAC/[email protected]> Mon, 8 Apr 2024 12:40:00 -0600
Newsgroups	gmane.org.user-groups.linux.nmglug
Message-ID	<[email protected]>
This is a multi-part message in MIME format.
--===============4275668429681659888==
Content-Type: multipart/alternative;
 boundary="------------7u0MXGkeRcZGo8ZJKsBnZ2Wb"
Content-Language: en-US

This is a multi-part message in MIME format.
--------------7u0MXGkeRcZGo8ZJKsBnZ2Wb
Content-Type: text/plain; charset=UTF-8; format=flowed
Content-Transfer-Encoding: 7bit

You are a much more patient person than I am. I would just use a distro 
with the Linux Libre kernel instead; so much work since HURD project has 
so many unfinished parts.

Great job though! Fun report to read.

JMH

On 4/7/24 5:08 PM, Brian O'Keefe wrote:
>
> Howdy
>
> I have been installing Debian GNU/Hurd 11 into a QEMU VM. I like the 
> fact that it doesn't use the linux kernel so a further bit down the 
> road to FOSS. Anyway, I have downloaded the 20323 NET.iso from the 
> Debian GNU/Hurd repository and installed it. Once installed it's 
> beautiful and I installed gnumeric and GIMP for testing. On a first 
> reboot I can log in via Debian console and then I run startx to get an 
> XFCE4 desktop. It uses the lightdm. However, there is no way to 
> cleanly shut the VM down and I resort to quitting which means on next 
> boot up I get a fsck as it wasn't shutdown properly. Once that is done 
> and I get a console prompt I login and run startx. I get some wait 
> time and then the menu bar at the top, a dock at the bottom and a 
> black screen with a black X cursor. I've restarted lightdm to no 
> avail. I can provide more details if anyone is interested in this. It 
> sure looks like a very good effort at getting a GNU/Hurd, operable, OS 
> out there.
>
> Here's what I've been using for info. BTW, the QEMU img that the 
> website says you can run is true. You can run it, but it is some very 
> weird version of a very antique GNU/Hurd distro. I would love to get 
> this working beyond this X window issue.
>
> For now it is essentially a time killer as I've reinstalled it 
> probably 20 times with always the same result.
>
> Cheers
>
> Brian
>
> -- 
>
> _______________________________________________
> nmglug mailing list
> [email protected]
> http://lists.nmglug.org/listinfo.cgi/nmglug-nmglug.org
--------------7u0MXGkeRcZGo8ZJKsBnZ2Wb
Content-Type: multipart/related;
 boundary="------------ooNH86VrcB3Vsqp8Fn0bkhMc"

--------------ooNH86VrcB3Vsqp8Fn0bkhMc
Content-Type: text/html; charset=UTF-8
Content-Transfer-Encoding: 7bit

<!DOCTYPE html>
<html>
  <head>
    <meta http-equiv="Content-Type" content="text/html; charset=UTF-8">
  </head>
  <body>
    <p>You are a much more patient person than I am. I would just use a
      distro with the Linux Libre kernel instead; so much work since
      HURD project has so many unfinished parts.</p>
    <p>Great job though! Fun report to read.</p>
    <p>JMH<br>
    </p>
    <div class="moz-cite-prefix">On 4/7/24 5:08 PM, Brian O'Keefe wrote:<br>
    </div>
    <blockquote type="cite"
      cite="mid:ab316202-df19-4fd1-8cf3-dcd4508a3938-NZlHNpfwZ0aB+jHODAdFcQ@public.gmane.org">
      <meta http-equiv="content-type" content="text/html; charset=UTF-8">
      <p>Howdy</p>
      <p>I have been installing Debian GNU/Hurd 11 into a QEMU VM. I
        like the fact that it doesn't use the linux kernel so a further
        bit down the road to FOSS. Anyway, I have downloaded the 20323
        NET.iso from the Debian GNU/Hurd repository and installed it.
        Once installed it's beautiful and I installed gnumeric and GIMP
        for testing. On a first reboot I can log in via Debian console
        and then I run startx to get an XFCE4 desktop. It uses the
        lightdm. However, there is no way to cleanly shut the VM down
        and I resort to quitting which means on next boot up I get a
        fsck as it wasn't shutdown properly. Once that is done and I get
        a console prompt I login and run startx. I get some wait time
        and then the menu bar at the top, a dock at the bottom and a
        black screen with a black X cursor. I've restarted lightdm to no
        avail. I can provide more details if anyone is interested in
        this. It sure looks like a very good effort at getting a
        GNU/Hurd, operable, OS out there.</p>
      <p>Here's what I've been using for info. BTW, the QEMU img that
        the website says you can run is true. You can run it, but it is
        some very weird version of a very antique GNU/Hurd distro. I
        would love to get this working beyond this X window issue.</p>
      <p>For now it is essentially a time killer as I've reinstalled it
        probably 20 times with always the same result.</p>
      <p>Cheers</p>
      <p>Brian <br>
      </p>
      <div class="moz-signature">-- <br>
        <img src="cid:part1.YaHgY0yb.bWrpXw9c-z41ulFnQs1aKQSNuG+CHvAC/[email protected]"
          class="" border="0"></div>
      <br>
      <fieldset class="moz-mime-attachment-header"></fieldset>
      <pre class="moz-quote-pre" wrap="">_______________________________________________
nmglug mailing list
<a class="moz-txt-link-abbreviated" href="mailto:[email protected]">[email protected]</a>
<a class="moz-txt-link-freetext" href="http://lists.nmglug.org/listinfo.cgi/nmglug-nmglug.org">http://lists.nmglug.org/listinfo.cgi/nmglug-nmglug.org</a>
</pre>
    </blockquote>
  </body>
</html>
--------------ooNH86VrcB3Vsqp8Fn0bkhMc
Content-Type: image/png; name="signature.png"
Content-Disposition: inline; filename="signature.png"
Content-Id: <part1.YaHgY0yb.bWrpXw9c-z41ulFnQs1aKQSNuG+CHvAC/[email protected]>
Content-Transfer-Encoding: base64
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--------------ooNH86VrcB3Vsqp8Fn0bkhMc--

--------------7u0MXGkeRcZGo8ZJKsBnZ2Wb--

--===============4275668429681659888==
Content-Type: text/plain; charset="us-ascii"
MIME-Version: 1.0
Content-Transfer-Encoding: 7bit
Content-Disposition: inline

_______________________________________________
nmglug mailing list
[email protected]
http://lists.nmglug.org/listinfo.cgi/nmglug-nmglug.org

--===============4275668429681659888==--