Are images GFDL'd?
"Tomos at Wikipedia" <[email protected]>
| Newsgroups | gmane.org.wikimedia.legal |
|---|---|
| Message-ID | <[email protected]> |
Hello. I think I have seen in the past that images used on Wikipedia are not under GFDL. That is one of the things I have never taken too seriously, but may be I should have. So now I am trying. And I apologize if my points are already raised and discussed in the past. In that case, I hope someone could point me the past discussion(s) that I can read and use to inform my fellow wikipedians at ja. If images are not under GFDL, and say, simply copyrighted by the person who uploaded, then I think there is a fair chance that downloading an image from an wikipedia and uploading to another wikipedia would constitute a copyright violation. I now quite a few people have done that at Japanese wikipedia, and I would definitely want to notify them to be careful. (The exception I can think is that the whole wikipedia in multiple languages is a single work...but I think nobody so far suggested or argued that it is the case.) I guess there is a page like [[Wikipedia:Image Usage Policy]] or something similar in each wikipedia. And it states that the person who upload an image has to be the copyright holder, a GFDL permission from the copyright holder, or the image has to be in public domain. I am inclined to say that all the people who uploaded the images they created did indeed agree that images will be released under GFDL. But the literal interpretation seems to allow some alternative take, like, "I am the copyright holder as this policy requires. And I am not asked to release my image under GFDL here, as far as I can understand from this policy. So I assume this image will not be used as a GFDL image." Of course, when we see image information page, there might be an explicit statement that the image is released under GFDL. That's good. But when such a notice is absent, should we be careful not to use those images as GFDL'd? As always, thank you for your attention. regards, Tomos _________________________________________________________________ Winterize your home with tips from MSN House & Home. http://special.msn.com/home/warmhome.armx