Re: Bug closing policy

Le 22 oct. 05 à 19:25, Markus Hitter a écrit :

>
> A few weeks ago I files a bug against one of OpenDarwin's web  
> pages: <http://bugzilla.opendarwin.org/show_bug.cgi?id=5114>. Not a  
> life-critical thing, but easy enough to fix.
>
> All of a sudden, the bug were closed as "Appears fixed". There is  
> no change at all, the web pages still misses a link as it was when  
> I submitted the bug. So either, the closing person didn't  
> understand the nature of the bug or the fix doesn't appear in the  
> public. I asked this closing person for explanation but didn't get  
> an answer.
>
> So may I humbly ask what's going on here? I don't file bugs because  
> I'm so bored. I want OpenDarwin to be more successful. Should I  
> reopen the bug at the risk of a Open - Close - Reopen - Reclose war?
>
>
> Thanks,
> Markus
>
>
> P.S.: As most of you probably know, Apple has the policy to ask the  
> submitter wether a fix was successful and the bug can be closed.

You mis-described the bug.
You wrote:

It's the page with the list of current OpenDarwin projects. The  
"darwinports" header is missing a link. Should probably point to  
http://opendarwin.org/projects/darwinbuild/ .

Darwinports header is correctly linked to the darwinports project.  
The problem is with the darwinbuild header. William didn't  
understand what you wrote and decided to close the bug.

Paul
-- 
Ministre ultraplénipotentiaire en disponibilité.
Mobile. Sans baignoire fixe.
http://www.kallisys.com/
http://www-poleia.lip6.fr/~guyot/