Re: Purpose of the list (was Re: [BPARK] Shugborough)

Matt asked <<if, say, another Enigma machine was stolen from BP, would discussion about it be off-topic?>>

It certainly was not deemed to be off topic at the time!

Regards

Bill Ridgeway

  ----- Original Message ----- 
  From: Matt R 
  To: BLETCHLEYPARK-0lvw86wZMd/[email protected] 
  Sent: Friday, November 26, 2004 11:58 AM
  Subject: [BPARK] Purpose of the list (was Re: [BPARK] Shugborough)


  (replies reordered to avoid mixed top-/bottom-posting)
   --- Geoff Sullivan <[email protected]> wrote:
  > In message <f05010428bdcc05239139@[195.40.198.44]>, J. V. Field writes:
  > >
  > >At 14:56 +0000 25.11.04, Geoff Sullivan wrote:
  > >>A bit OT, I think you're posting to the wrong group.
  > >
  > >   Surely not.  The ex-BP people had made the only real crypto point
  > >about the inscription.
  > The origin of this group was the Cranfield hosted list, archived on
  > eGroups/Yahoo, now moved to KSU. its purpose defined /*here*/
  >
  > I stand by my original comment.
  >
  > Geoff
  >
  > /*
  > Welcome to the Bletchley Park mailing list.
  > messages to all the members of the list can be sent to
  >
  > BletchleyPark-MISrrjN62/[email protected]
  >
  > As many of you know, Bletchley Park was the site of the UK decryption
  > effort during the Second World War. Its activities massive; its success
  > spectacular. Its existence was kept secret for decades. One purpose
  > of this list is to discuss the activities and techniques employed by
  > Bletchley Park during the war.
  >
  > Today, a small group are working to create a musuem of early computing
  > and cryptography at the site. This effort is suffering from a lack
  > of funding. Its applications for government money have so far failed.
  > A second function of this list is to discuss ideas about how to get
  > the site securely set aside for the purposes of a museum. There is
  > a real possibility that the site will end up as a housing development.
  > */

  Fair enough, sorry if my posting was not within the charter of the mailing
  list. I'd suggest that the "Welcome" message for joining the list might be
  modified to inform a newcomer of this, otherwise they might be tempted to post
  about topics related to Bletchley Park outside of the above defined scope.

  However, I'd also like to suggest that the group might consider allowing
  discussion on any topic related to Bletchley Park -- are there reasons for
  sticking just to 1) war-time BP and 2) securing the site as a museum? For
  example, if, say, another Enigma machine was stolen from BP, would discussion
  about it be off-topic?

  Matt



  ___________________________________________________________
  Win a castle for NYE with your mates and Yahoo! Messenger
  http://uk.messenger.yahoo.com