Re: German sharp S uppercase mapping

On 12/1/2024 9:09 PM, David Starner via Unicode wrote:
> On Sun, Dec 1, 2024 at 7:54 PM Dominikus Dittes Scherkl via Unicode
> <[email protected]> wrote:
>> But in automatic text processing the old form is simply a bug that needs
>> to be fixed. The new form has to be the "default" - otherwise
>> implementations will proliferate this bug forever.
> Various systems take for granted that case folding is stable.
Very much agreed on that one. Usually in the context of "identifiers" 
and not in free text.
> Differences in how Unicode data is interpreted has open security holes
> in systems, and while this isn't particularly likely with this change,
> it is possible, which is part of the reason case-folding is guaranteed
> to be stable. Such a change can confuse case-insensitive filesystems,
> or change the interpretation of code in case-insensitive filesystems.
> The automated default isn't going to change, and German is going to
> have to join Turkish in that purely default case-conversion just
> doesn't work for them.
>
Again, it would help to mentally change from "default" to some other 
term, like the "InvariantCulture" terminology used by .NET, for example.

By "default", if I start editing a document, I should not have to worry 
about getting a deficient case mapping/case conversion implementation 
just because I'm using the "wrong" language.

Likewise, by default, I should never get the locale-dependent case 
conversion invoked when accessing file systems or domain names.

These are different "defaults".

A./