Re: b4 review state is broken after series reorders patches?

On Mon, 06 Apr 2026 13:59:31 -0400, Konstantin Ryabitsev wrote:
> - Maintainer writes reviews for v1 and sends them
> - Sender provides v2 in response to feedback
> - Maintainer upgrades to v2 and we carry forward all previous reviews 
>   (but they were already sent, so may or may not be relevant for v2)
> 
> Let me see if we can improve what happens in this scenario.

There is an attempted fix in master. We're now marking comments that 
were sent with sent-revision and will do two things on series upgrade:

- not carry them forward to identical patches from vN to vN+1
- will automatically mark identical patches as "skip" on upgrade, so you 
  should only see patches that have changed

This won't work retroactively, but should kick in next time you send a 
reply to a series.

There are probably still lots of buggy corner-cases with reviews and 
upgrades, so please keep sending the reports in as you discover them.

Best wishes,
-- 
KR