A DVD that only runs on some players

Philip Walden <[email protected]> Mon, 24 Sep 2012 11:54:05 -0700
Newsgroups gmane.comp.multimedia.dvdauthor.user
Message-ID <[email protected]>
I have question about DVD limits.

http://en.wikibooks.org/wiki/Inside_DVD-Video/Limits

I have a set of 3 webcams monitoring motion events outside the house. I 
use a perl script and DVDStyler to produce a DVD with 4 months of daily 
motion movies. the structure is:

VGM:
    Select Month in Year

Titleset 1: (first month)
    Select Day on Month menu: 28-31 day buttons + 1 Back (to VGM) button
    28-31 Titles
        Each Title consists of 3 VOB references pointing to the a 
camera's daily movie.

Titleset(s) 2-4: (same as Titleset 1)

The problem is that the DVD is produced, but only works on some players. 
I have a older Philips DVD player that works fine. My newer Sony Blu-Ray 
player basically "hangs" on it and I have to power cycle it to get it to 
spit out the DVD. Every PC-based player I have tried also works fine. A 
friend with a newer DVD player has problems.

Using the DVD limits reference, I believe I am just under the 
menu-button limit of 36 for narrow screen. All the the movies and menus 
are 4:3.  The other concern is 99 titles in a titleset, but even if a 
VOB is counted as a title, I never have more than 93.

So have I exceeded some limit I am unaware of, or is the Sony player 
deficient? Or is the "but only 12 [buttons per menu] at once for 
widescreen" biting me with the newer player as they are always widescreen?

Here are some xml snippets:

<titleset>
<menus>
<video aspect="4:3"/>
<audio lang="EN"/>
<subpicture lang="EN"/>
<pgc entry="root">
<button name="button1">g0=button;jump title 1;</button>
<button name="button2">g0=button;jump title 2;</button>
<button name="button3">g0=button;jump title 3;</button>
          :
<button name="button31">g0=button;jump vmgm menu 2;</button>
<vob 
file="/home/pwalden/Videos/DVDProjects/webcam/2011-09-12/dvd-tmp/menu1-0.mpg"/>
<pre>if (g1==1 and g0&gt;0) button = g0; else button = 1024;g1=1;</pre>
</pgc>
</menus>
<titles>
<video aspect="4:3"/>
<audio lang="EN"/>
<pgc>
<vob chapters="1:00,2:00,3:00,4:00,5:00,6:00,7:00,8:00,9:00" 
file="/opt2/pwalden/webcam/cam1/2011/09/01/01.mpg"/>
<vob chapters="1:00,2:00,3:00,4:00,5:00,6:00,7:00,8:00,9:00" 
file="/opt2/pwalden/webcam/cam2/2011/09/01/01.mpg"/>
<vob chapters="1:00,2:00,3:00,4:00,5:00,6:00,7:00,8:00,9:00" 
file="/opt2/pwalden/webcam/cam3/2011/09/01/01.mpg"/>
<post>g1 = 0;call menu;</post>
</pgc>
<pgc>
<vob chapters="1:00,2:00,3:00,4:00,5:00,6:00,7:00,8:00,9:00" 
file="/opt2/pwalden/webcam/cam1/2011/09/02/02.mpg"/>
<vob chapters="1:00,2:00,3:00,4:00,5:00,6:00,7:00,8:00,9:00" 
file="/opt2/pwalden/webcam/cam2/2011/09/02/02.mpg"/>
<vob chapters="1:00,2:00,3:00,4:00,5:00,6:00,7:00,8:00,9:00" 
file="/opt2/pwalden/webcam/cam3/2011/09/02/02.mpg"/>
<post>g1 = 0;call menu;</post>
</pgc>
        : etc


------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Live Security Virtual Conference
Exclusive live event will cover all the ways today's security and 
threat landscape has changed and how IT managers can respond. Discussions 
will include endpoint security, mobile security and the latest in malware 
threats. http://www.accelacomm.com/jaw/sfrnl04242012/114/50122263/