Re: Protection of hyphen

Martin Duerst <[email protected]>
Newsgroups gmane.ietf.imaa
Message-ID <4.2.0.58.J.20030422213322.05a50258@localhost>
At 12:27 03/04/22 +0100, Roy Badami wrote:


>  > Note that "owner-listname" is a prime example of why we might *not*
>  > want to protect the hyphen. The hyphen in that name is not for making
>  > subaddresses: it is just there for preventing the two names from
>  > smooshing together.
>
>But some software (eg sendmail) has special knowledge of the
>owner-listname construct.
>
>I wonder how much mailing list management software has things like
>owner-listname or listname-request hardwired?  (Note: I'm not saying
>that this is a big problem in practice; I'm just posing the question.)
>
>Also hyphen is the default delimiter for subaddressing in qmail
>(though this is easily changed, so may not matter so much).

Can it be changed on a per-installation basis, or on a per-user
basis, or on a per-main-address basis? Can it be changed by the
user, or does it need system priviledges?

If we need a sysadmin to change it, and it applies to all users
and all existing and future addresses, then this is a serious problem.
If each user can change it, per address (many users will want to
have both a traditional ASCII address and an IMA), then that's
probably okay.


Regards,   Martin.
lmpx.com only provides a reader for public news (NNTP) servers. It is not affiliated with the servers or forums shown here and is not responsible for the content of articles, which is written by their respective authors.