Re: New issue 16: No packets from other end?

 In your previous mail you wrote:

      (2) Its not okay. MOBIKE/IKEv2/IPsec should fail and
          wait for the rest of the stack to inform when there's
          again an operational address.
   
          If problems on the path need to be handled, this would
          imply the development of a new, separate protocol for
          testing paths. Note that ICMP/TCP/app may already have
          told us of a problem with the current communications just
          as DPD did. But what we need is finding _another_ pair
          that works. No protocol that I know does that right now.
          Most of what we have in IPv6/DNA etc is focused on local
          issues, such as availability of the router.
   
=> this is true only because you take all your examples from
the mobility world, not from the multi-homing one which is
some years late compared to mobility. So IMHO your argument
is wrong and there will be an external mechanism which is able
to find another pair that works, ...

Regards

[email protected]