Re: News Flash: CFV: Test link vote for quiche.fr.eu.blitzed.org

Andy Smith wrote:
>>Testlink votes could IMHO be send to staff@lists, with a rationale  
>>for the vote choice. All other votes should (again IMHO) be send in  
>>private to [email protected]
> 
> So you don't think it is worth having consistency then?
> 
> What do the vote counters think?
> 
> Personally I think a) you underestimate how much of a mess it is
> when half the admins vote to one place and half to another and even
> some with the wrong method, and b) there is no logical reason for
> some votes to be cast in public and others not.

Although I am not one to really get too involved in this discussion 
(being a non-vote counter), I just thought I'd give my 2 cents worth.

For sake of consistency and to not cause confusion, I suggest 
everything vote related goes to [email protected] The only 
disadvantage of this is if other staff members (i.e. non-admins) 
want to track a vote's progress; not very important I know, but in 
which case the staff list would be the better option. Also, is there 
any real reason why it should be kept so private that other staff 
members can't see the status of a vote? Just curious :)

Cheers,

-- 
Simon Pearson